Skip to content
TEACH THIS WAY! · TEACHER-CREATED RESOURCES
School & Classroom Success

Using Small Instructional Adjustments to Make a Big Difference

Teach This Way! editorial · Last updated · 8 min read

Small, low-prep changes to scaffolding, checking for understanding and grouping that help more students learn without redesigning your whole lesson.

Facebook Pinterest Email

When a lesson isn't working, it is tempting to think the answer is a new curriculum, a new program or a complete redesign. Often the bigger gains come from small moves inside the lesson you already have: one better question, a worked example before independent practice, a two-minute check before moving on, a quick regroup for the students who need it.

This article is for K-12 classroom teachers, special educators, interventionists and instructional coaches, with notes for related service providers and leaders. It focuses on four kinds of adjustment: scaffolding, checking for understanding, flexible grouping and responsive instruction.

Why Small Adjustments Matter

In "Principles of Instruction" (2012), published in the AFT's American Educator, Barak Rosenshine drew on cognitive science, studies of effective teachers and research on cognitive supports to describe ten principles. Several are small, repeatable moves rather than big programs: present new material in small steps, ask many questions and check the responses of all students, guide student practice, provide models and scaffolds for difficult tasks, and aim for a high success rate. Summaries of his work commonly report that the most effective teachers in the studies he reviewed reached about 80 percent success during guided practice, which suggests the material was challenging but not out of reach.

In their 1998 article "Inside the Black Box," Paul Black and Dylan Wiliam argued that formative assessment (using evidence of student understanding to adjust teaching while learning is still happening) is one of the most promising ways to raise standards. Their practical recommendations included more wait time, getting responses from more students, and feedback that tells students how to improve.

The IES practice guide Organizing Instruction and Study to Improve Student Learning (Pashler et al., 2007) adds a few more well-supported adjustments: alternating worked examples with problems students solve themselves, spacing review over time, using quizzing to re-expose students to key content, and asking deep explanatory questions.

Key Insights

  • "Any questions?" is not a check for understanding. Silence often means confusion, not mastery.
  • Scaffolds are temporary by design. In a 2010 review in Educational Psychology Review, Janneke van de Pol, Monique Volman and Jos Beishuizen described three features of scaffolding: contingency (support matched to the student's current understanding), fading (reducing support over time) and transfer of responsibility (the student gradually takes over). A support that never fades can become a crutch.
  • Groups should change with the evidence. Flexible grouping means groups form around today's need and dissolve when the need is met. Fixed "low groups" that last all year are a different practice and can limit students' opportunities.
  • Small adjustments compound. A two-minute check that catches a misconception today can save a full reteach next week.

Practical Strategies

Scaffolding

  • Worked example first. Model one problem thinking aloud, then have students complete a partially worked example, then solve one independently.
  • Sentence frames and starters for discussion and writing ("I think ___ because ___." "One piece of evidence is ___.").
  • Chunk the task. Break a multi-step assignment into parts with a check after each.
  • Visual supports: anchor charts, graphic organizers, labeled diagrams.
  • Plan the fade. Decide in advance when you will remove the frame or the organizer.

Checking for understanding

  • All-response checks: mini whiteboards, response cards, fingers for multiple choice.
  • Hinge questions: one carefully chosen multiple-choice question at a key point, with wrong answers that reveal specific misconceptions.
  • Explain-to-a-partner: students explain a step in their own words while you listen to several pairs.
  • Exit tickets: one or two questions that tell you who is ready to move on.

Flexible grouping

  • After a check, pull a small group of students who showed the same error for a five-minute reteach while others practice.
  • Offer an extension group for students who are ready.
  • Mix groupings over the week: needs-based groups, mixed-readiness partners, interest groups.
  • Keep records simple so groups change: a class list with a check, a minus or a star after each exit ticket is enough.

Responsive instruction

  • Plan a decision point: "If most boards are right, move to practice. If not, reteach with a second example."
  • Keep a second explanation ready (a different representation, model or analogy).
  • Use spaced review: revisit important content from previous weeks in warm-ups.
  • Give feedback that points forward. John Hattie and Helen Timperley (2007) framed useful feedback around three questions: Where am I going? How am I going? Where to next?

How to Put This Into Practice

  1. Pick one lesson you teach often. Small changes are easiest to test on familiar material.
  2. Find the hardest step. Where do students usually get stuck? Add a worked example or a scaffold right there.
  3. Add one check for understanding before independent practice, with an all-response format.
  4. Write a decision rule for what you will do with the results.
  5. Prepare a five-minute reteach for a small group.
  6. Collect an exit ticket and use it to plan the first five minutes of the next lesson.
  7. Reflect after a week: what changed in student work? Keep what worked and try one more adjustment.

If sorting through results feels overwhelming, see Using Classroom Data to Improve Instruction Without Becoming Overwhelmed. For quick reference lists, try the Classroom Checklists.

A Realistic Example

This is a composite scenario, not a real teacher or school.

A sixth-grade math teacher introduced ratios with a short explanation and then assigned a practice page. About a third of the class struggled, and she spent independent practice running from desk to desk answering the same question again and again.

The next time, she made three changes. She modeled one problem thinking aloud, then gave a second problem with the first step completed. She added a hinge question on whiteboards before practice, with one wrong answer that showed students were adding instead of multiplying. When eight boards showed that answer, she pulled those students to a table for five minutes with a ratio table drawn out, while the rest started practice. The next day, the eight students began with a partially completed table, and by the end of the week most no longer needed it.

Total extra prep was about fifteen minutes. The big change was that she found the misconception before practice instead of after.

What to Do When It Doesn't Work

  • The check shows almost everyone is confused. That's useful information. Reteach the whole class with a different explanation rather than pushing forward.
  • Students rely on scaffolds and won't let go. Fade gradually: remove one part of the frame, then another, and praise independent attempts.
  • Small groups disrupt the rest of the class. Teach the routine for independent work first, with clear tasks and a "what to do when stuck" plan, before running groups. Creating Classroom Routines That Actually Work can help.
  • The same students are always in the reteach group. Look for underlying gaps and consult your intervention or special education team. Repeated difficulty may signal a need for more intensive, targeted support.
  • There isn't time. Start with one hinge question per lesson. It takes two minutes.

Adapting for Different Settings and Roles

Elementary

Use concrete materials and visuals as scaffolds, and keep checks quick and frequent. Small-group rotations are often already in place; make sure membership changes with the evidence.

Secondary

Hinge questions and exit tickets fit well even in large classes. Worked examples are powerful in math and science, and model paragraphs or annotated texts work similarly in English and social studies.

Special education

Many of these adjustments are already familiar in special education. Make sure accommodations and supports in IEPs and 504 plans are provided as written; those requirements are not optional scaffolds to fade on your own. Plan with the IEP team before reducing any documented support. Co-teachers can split the room for flexible groups. For coordination ideas, see Building Stronger Collaboration With Special Education and Related Service Professionals.

English learners

Language scaffolds (frames, word banks, visuals, partner rehearsal) let students access grade-level content while building English.

Related service providers

SLPs can help design language scaffolds, and OTs can suggest adapted materials or tools for writing and manipulatives. Sharing these with classroom teachers spreads their benefit across the day.

Coaches and leaders

Coaching around one small adjustment at a time is more manageable than broad feedback. Protecting time for teams to look at exit tickets together makes responsive teaching realistic.

Try This Tomorrow

  • Replace "Any questions?" with one all-response question before independent practice.
  • Model one problem aloud, then give students a partially completed version before the full task.
  • Use tomorrow's exit ticket to form one five-minute small group the next day.

Quick Takeaways

  • Small, repeatable moves (small steps, checks for understanding, guided practice, scaffolds) are central to effective instruction.
  • Scaffolds should match the student's current understanding and fade over time, except for documented IEP or 504 supports.
  • Flexible groups form and dissolve based on evidence.
  • Planning a decision point turns a check into a real adjustment.

Reflection Questions

  • Where in my lessons do students most often get stuck, and what support do I offer at that point?
  • How do I know, before independent practice, who is ready?
  • Do my small groups change over time, or have they become fixed?
  • Which scaffold am I ready to start fading?

Sources & Further Reading

← More from School & Classroom Success